Reasons for drug policy reform: prohibition enables systemic human rights abuses and undermines public health.
نویسندگان
چکیده
Drug prohibition, including criminalisation to regulate the supply and demand of controlled substances, has had devastating effects on human rights and public health worldwide. Prohibition as an international policy response gives rise to illicit drugmarkets governed by criminal networks and regulated by violence. The poor and marginalised communities in which illicit drugs are cultivated, transited, or sold are disproportionately affected. States have responded with increased law enforcement, escalating violence and further destabilising communities. Parallel violent pursuits both to protect and to topple illicit markets have been linked to large scale displacement, femicide, and an overall decrease in life expectancy, such as in Mexico. Mass incarceration to enforce prohibition has overburdened criminal justice systems and left countless people languishing in deplorable facilities in inhumane conditions around the world.Criminalisation of possessionmeans that a fifth of people who use drugs spend much of their lives cycling through the criminal justice system, with serious social, economic, and health consequences. In prisons, people who inject drugs have limited or no access to healthcare, including harm reduction interventions such as clean needles and opioid substitution treatment. 4 Custodial settings are a high risk environment for transmission of HIV and hepatitis C, particularly for people who inject drugs, and these infections have broader public health consequences once people are released. Despite the devastating health and human rights effects, incarceration has failed to deter drug consumption or trafficking. Outside the criminal justice system, the pursuit of prohibition has given rise to compulsory detention centres, where people identified as drug users may be held without due process and subjected to torture, physical and sexual violence, and forced labour in the name of “treatment.” In East and South East Asia alone, an estimated 250 000 people are held in these facilities despite evidence of their ineffectiveness in treating drug dependence. Compulsory detention of drug users violates the right to health and is inhuman, degrading, and “inherently arbitrary” under international human rights law. Outside prison, criminalisation and stigma associated with drug use have been recurrent barriers to accessing healthcare, including scientifically proved harm reduction treatment. Punitive models of drug control such as registries of drug users, reporting requirements for health professionals, legal bans on the provision of substitution treatment, and police raids near healthcare facilities deter people from accessing healthcare, driving drug use underground and increasing health risks. Prohibition has been linked to a growing epidemic of opioid overdose in North America, where unnecessary restrictions on overdose treatment, lack of substitution treatment, and aggressive policing contribute to preventable mortality. Laws banning opioids such as methadone and morphine for medically indicated treatment and regulations unnecessarily restricting their prescription or use undermine healthcare professionals in the delivery of ethical healthcare As a result, four fifths of the world lack adequate access to drugs for palliative care and slightly less than half of countries worldwide have frameworks in place to enable the provision of opioid substitution treatment. Bold initiatives have emerged in recent years that show there are other ways to tackle the complex dimensions of drugs that can reduce harms and improve public health outcomes. In countries such as the Czech Republic, Switzerland, and Portugal, longstanding decriminalisation models based on public health
منابع مشابه
The Urgency to Mitigate the Spread of Hepatitis C in Pakistan Through Blood Transfusion Reform
Blood transfusions are contributing to a higher rate of hepatitis C virus (HCV) in Pakistan. Half of all blood transfusions in Pakistan are not screened for hepatitis C, hepatitis B or HIV. Family members donate blood that is likely not tested due to social stigma attached to HCV. Paid donations are also quite common in the country, especially by people who inject drugs (PWID), which increases ...
متن کاملYouth subcultures, normalisation and drug prohibition: The politics of contemporary crisis and change?
This article provides a new reading of the crossover between youth subculture and drug consumption, and seeks to demonstrate that drug prohibition has entered a legitimation crisis in social and political policy (Habermas, 1975). This article argues that contemporary drug normalisation is at the centre of the apparent failure of drug prohibition to understand and respond to the growth in opposi...
متن کاملHealth Reform Requires Policy Capacity
Among the many reasons that may limit the adoption of promising reform ideas, policy capacity is the least recognized. The concept itself is not widely understood. Although policy capacity is concerned with the gathering of information and the formulation of options for public action in the initial phases of policy consultation and development, it also touches on all stages of the policy proces...
متن کاملForced sterilization of women as discrimination
There has been a long history of subjecting marginalized women to forced and coerced sterilization. In recent years, the practice has been documented in countries in North and South America, Europe, Asia, and Africa. It has targeted women who are ethnic and racial minorities, women with disabilities, women living with HIV, and poor women. A handful of courts have issued decisions on the recent ...
متن کاملHave Health Human Resources Become More Equal Between Rural and Urban Areas after the New Reform?
The lack of health human resources is a global issue. China also faces the same issue, in addition to the equity of human resources allocation. With the launch of new healthcare reform of China in 2009, have the issues been improved? Relevant data from China Health Statistical Yearbook and a qualitative study show that the unequal allocation of health human resources is getting worse than before.
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید
ثبت ناماگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید
ورودعنوان ژورنال:
- BMJ
دوره 356 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2017